I Made HOW Much ?!?!

This past week CMS released Provider Utilization and Payment Data: information on services and procedures provided to Medicare beneficiaries by physicians and other healthcare professionals. In case you weren’t following along, there has been quite a bit of controversy over the data release, including from both the American Medical Association and the Medical Group Practice Association.

Donald W. Fisher, Ph.D, MGMA President & CEO:
MGMA is troubled about the potential for unintended consequences as a result of the release of this type of data and the effect it may have on Medicare beneficiaries. This release could result in patients making decisions about their care based on faulty assumptions about physicians. Claims data are not a proxy for quality, especially when provided in isolation, from a single payer.
MGMA is also concerned about the impact on physician privacy, as releasing physician’s personal financial data and National Provider Identifier (NPI) information could make providers susceptible to fraud. Physicians should have had the opportunity to review the data before it was made publicly available in order to modify or appeal any inaccuracies.

Ardis Dee Hoven, MD, President of the AMA:
Thoughtful observers concluded long ago that payments or costs were not the only metric to evaluate medical care. Quality, value and outcomes are critical yardsticks for patients. The information released by CMS will not allow patients or payers to draw meaningful conclusions about the value or quality of care.The AMA is disappointed that CMS did not include reasonable safeguards that would help the public understand the limitations of this data.

Back in February of 2013 I wrote, Pick a Price – Any Price, describing how and why healthcare provider pricing is typically both misleading while at the same time meaningless. But the focus then and there was on hospitals. People in general are a lot more envious of other people than they are buildings and groups of people working in those buildings. Thus you can easily understand why there is concern over public perceptions – particularly when those perceptions are likely to be different than reality in most instances because of not understanding how to interpret the data.

Theoretically, I weigh this concern against a belief that in most cases more information is better than less.  Obvious exceptions include issues of personal privacy and national security. Transparency and accountability should be hallmark pursuits of the Medicare system. And I think most physicians are in favor of sharing data that helps empower the patient to make more informed healthcare decisions.

It is not at all clear the data released last week will be able to do that any time soon. In fact, the arguments positing the data’s release will do more damage than good are persuasive. These include a lack of any data on quality; inability to track actual service levels to individuals providing those services; misunderstanding of charges versus payment; inability to risk adjust for patients treated; no adjustments for site of service differences; discrepancies caused by changes in billing codes; and – most importantly – no way of knowing how much reimbursement the physician uses to cover overhead costs, which is required in order to determine real income.

So on balance I have to side with the physician groups on this one. CMS made a very poor decision to release the data, as-is, without any real thought about releasing it with all of the disclaimers addressing the issues and concerns described above. I hesitate to say it – but I say what I think – this sure feels like another backdoor attempt to promote victimization at the expense of disinformation.

Cheers,
  Sparky

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Policy Prescriptions ®

Advocates for Evidence-Based Health Policy™

Health Affairs BlogHealth Affairs Blog

mission: to inform & educate

ChangingAging

with Dr. Bill Thomas

%d bloggers like this: